The music industry has transformed dramatically over the past two decades, with streaming services like Spotify, Apple Music, and YouTube dominating consumption. In 2023, streaming accounted for 84% of U.S. recorded music revenue, totaling $14.4 billion, while physical media—CDs and vinyl—generated $1.9 billion, or 11% of the market. Despite streaming’s dominance, physical media retains a loyal following due to its unique advantages. A critical factor in this landscape is the income artists and songwriters earn from each format, which varies significantly. This article explores the granular data behind streaming’s rise, the enduring appeal of CDs and vinyl, the decline of playback devices, and the financial implications for musicians, highlighting why physical media sales at concert merchandise tables remain a viable revenue stream.
The Dominance of Streaming: Convenience, Scale, and Data
Streaming’s ascendancy is driven by its convenience, accessibility, and scalability. A Spotify Premium subscription (~$10.99/month in 2025) provides access to over 100 million tracks, enabling listeners to enjoy music anywhere via smartphones, tablets, or computers without physical storage or playback devices. This portability supports music consumption during commutes, workouts, or travel, unlike CDs or vinyl, which require dedicated players and physical space.
Streaming excels in music discovery, with algorithms and curated playlists (e.g., Spotify’s “Discover Weekly”) introducing users to new artists and genres, a dynamic experience physical media cannot match. Paid subscriptions in the U.S. grew 4% in 2023 to $5.7 billion, nearly two-thirds of total music revenue. Streaming integrates seamlessly with digital ecosystems—smart speakers (e.g., Amazon Echo), car infotainment systems, and wearables—while offline downloading mitigates connectivity issues. Environmentally, streaming reduces physical production (plastic, packaging), though data centers’ energy use rivals vinyl manufacturing unless offset by offline listening.
Granular Data on Streaming:
-
Streaming generated $14.4 billion in U.S. revenue in 2023, up 8.2% from 2022 (Recording Industry Association of America, RIAA).
-
Streaming’s 84% market share included 78% from subscriptions ($12.7 billion) and 6% from ad-supported platforms ($1.7 billion).
-
Global streaming revenue reached $28.9 billion in 2023, up 10.4% (International Federation of the Phonographic Industry, IFPI).
-
Spotify reported 239 million paid subscribers globally in Q4 2023; Apple Music claimed over 100 million songs.
-
In 2022, 76% of U.S. music revenue came from streaming, with a 7% rise in paid subscriptions in 2023.
-
Consumer behavior: 68% of U.S. listeners used streaming as their primary format in 2023, with 82% of Gen Z favoring streaming (Statista).
The Enduring Appeal of Physical Media: CDs and Vinyl
Physical media offers distinct advantages that sustain its niche. CDs provide uncompressed 44.1kHz/16-bit audio, surpassing streaming’s compressed formats (e.g., Spotify’s 320 kbps Ogg Vorbis, Apple Music’s 256 kbps AAC). Vinyl’s analog warmth is prized by audiophiles, though its superiority is debated. A 2023 MusicWatch survey found 89% of physical media buyers valued CDs for sound quality, and 72% preferred vinyl for its “authentic” experience.
Physical media ensures ownership and permanence, unaffected by streaming’s licensing volatility. Albums can disappear from platforms, as seen with Childish Gambino’s Awaken, My Love! briefly leaving Spotify in 2022 or Taylor Swift’s catalog being pulled in 2014. CDs and vinyl offer tactile engagement—booklets, gatefolds, and liner notes foster emotional connections streaming’s interfaces lack. Vinyl’s collectible appeal drives its resurgence, especially among Gen Z, who view records as decor or gifts. A 2023 YouGov poll showed 48% of U.S. adults enjoy physical copies, with 53% of 18–24-year-olds favoring their “special” feel.
Granular Data on Physical Media:
-
Vinyl: Sold 43 million units in 2023, generating $1.4 billion (71% of physical revenue), up 6.6% in volume (RIAA). Vinyl outsold CDs for the second year, a milestone not seen since 1987.
-
CDs: Sold 37 million units, generating ~$537 million, down 1.9% in volume but up 11.3% in revenue due to premium editions. Sales are 95% below their 2000 peak (942.5 million units).
-
Global Trends:
-
Germany: CDs held a 12.9% market share in 2023, down 5.9%; vinyl grew 19.4% (IFPI).
-
UK: CD sales fell 2.9% to 10.5 million units in 2024, slower than 2023’s 23.7% drop; vinyl rose 11.7% to 6.2 million (British Phonographic Industry, BPI).
-
Japan: Sold 49 million CDs in 2023, down 7%, driven by K-pop and J-pop (RIAJ).
-
Consumer Sentiment: 70% of physical media buyers prioritize artist support, vs. 52% of the general population (MusicWatch, 2023).
-
Vinyl Resurgence: Vinyl sales grew for 16 years, with 2023 revenue ($1.4 billion) the highest since 1988. Top albums: Taylor Swift’s Midnights (1.1 million units), The Beatles’ Abbey Road (400,000 units).
-
CD Decline: CD revenue fell below $1 billion in 2018 ($698 million), the lowest since 1986, until premium releases boosted 2023.
Artist and Songwriter Income: Streaming vs. Physical Media
The financial impact of streaming and physical media on artists and songwriters is a critical distinction, as income structures differ significantly. Streaming’s low per-stream payouts contrast with physical media’s higher per-unit margins, affecting musicians’ livelihoods and making physical sales at concerts a vital revenue stream.
Streaming Income
Streaming platforms pay artists and songwriters through complex royalty structures, split between master recording rights (held by artists or labels) and publishing rights (held by songwriters and publishers). Payouts are fractional, requiring massive stream counts to generate significant income.
-
Per-Stream Rates:
-
Spotify: ~$0.003–$0.005 per stream (average ~$0.004). A million streams yield ~$4,000, split among rights holders.
-
Apple Music: ~$0.008 per stream, yielding ~$8,000 per million streams.
-
YouTube: ~$0.0007 per stream, yielding ~$700 per million streams (lowest due to ad-based revenue).
-
Royalty Splits:
-
Master royalties (50–60% of streaming revenue): Paid to artists (if independent) or labels (who may pay artists 15–20% after recouping advances).
-
Publishing royalties (10–15%): Split between songwriters and publishers, often 50/50. Mechanical royalties (~$0.0008 per stream) are a subset, paid to songwriters for reproduction.
-
Challenges:
-
Labels take a significant cut, leaving artists with ~$0.0008–$0.001 per stream after splits. An independent artist needs 1.25 million streams to earn $5,000.
-
Songwriters earn less, with publishing royalties averaging $0.0004–$0.0008 per stream. A million streams might net a songwriter $400–$800.
-
Streaming favors top-tier artists. In 2023, 1% of artists (e.g., Taylor Swift, Drake) accounted for 30% of streams, per Spotify Wrapped, leaving mid-tier and independent artists struggling.
-
2023 Data:
-
Streaming paid $12.7 billion to rights holders in the U.S., but only ~20% ($2.54 billion) reached artists directly, per RIAA estimates.
-
Songwriters earned ~$1.2 billion globally from streaming, with 80% going to the top 10% of writers (CISAC, 2023).
-
An artist needs 314,500 streams/month to earn U.S. minimum wage ($1,257), per Soundcharts.
Physical Media Income
Physical media offers higher per-unit margins, especially for direct sales. CDs and vinyl sold at retail or concerts yield significantly more than streaming per unit.
-
Per-Unit Earnings:
-
CDs: Retail price
$15. After manufacturing ($2–$3) and distribution (~30%), artists earn ~$3–$5 per CD via labels. At concerts, artists keep $10–$12 after costs. -
Vinyl: Retail price ~$25–$40. Manufacturing costs ~$5–$8; distribution takes ~30%. Artists earn ~$5–$10 via labels, or $15–$25 at concerts.
-
Royalty Splits:
-
Master royalties: Artists receive 10–20% of wholesale price (~$1–$2 for CDs, $2–$4 for vinyl) through labels.
-
Mechanical royalties: Songwriters earn ~$0.091 per track (U.S. Copyright Royalty Board, 2023), or ~$0.91 for a 10-track CD/vinyl, split with publishers.
-
** Advantages**:
-
Direct sales at concerts bypass distributors, maximizing profits. A $15 CD yields $10–$12; a $25 vinyl yields $15–$20.
-
Independent artists control production, retaining 70–80% of sales revenue vs. 20% from streaming after label cuts.
-
Songwriters benefit from mechanical royalties, which are fixed and not diluted by stream volume, unlike streaming’s fractional payouts.
-
2023 Data:
-
Physical media paid ~$1.9 billion to rights holders, with artists earning ~$570 million (30%) and songwriters ~$190 million (10%), per RIAA estimates.
-
A single CD sale at a concert equals ~3,000 streams in artist income; a vinyl sale equals ~5,000–6,000 streams.
-
70% of physical media buyers purchase to support artists, boosting concert sales (MusicWatch, 2023).
Which Is More Advantageous in 2025?
Streaming is advantageous for:
-
Exposure: High stream counts amplify visibility, driving tour attendance and merchandise sales. In 2023, 80% of concertgoers discovered artists via streaming (Live Nation).
-
Top-Tier Artists: Megastars like Beyoncé or The Weeknd earn millions from streaming due to billions of streams, with Spotify paying $100 million to its top 100 artists in 2023.
-
Low Overhead: No manufacturing or distribution costs, ideal for digital-first artists.
Physical Media is advantageous for:
-
Mid-Tier/Independent Artists: Higher per-unit margins make physical sales more lucrative. Selling 100 CDs at $15 ($1,000–$1,200) surpasses 300,000 streams (~$1,200).
-
Songwriters: Fixed mechanical royalties ($0.91/album) outpace streaming’s $0.0008/track, especially for albums with multiple writers.
-
Direct Revenue: Concert sales yield 70–80% profit vs. streaming’s 20% after label cuts.
Current Advantage: Physical media is more financially advantageous for mid-tier and independent artists and songwriters in 2025, particularly via concert sales. Streaming’s low payouts require unsustainable stream volumes (e.g., 1.25 million/month for minimum wage), while a single CD or vinyl sale equals thousands of streams. However, streaming’s exposure drives long-term revenue through tours and merch, making it complementary for top-tier artists.
Physical Media at Concert Merch Tables
Selling physical media at concert merchandise tables remains financially viable due to:
-
High Margins: Artists keep $10–$12 per $15 CD and $15–$25 per $25–$40 vinyl, vs. $3–$10 through retail. Selling 50 CDs ($500–$600) or 30 vinyls ($450–$750) per show is feasible for mid-sized acts.
-
Fan Engagement: 70% of concertgoers buy merch to support artists, with 40% purchasing CDs or vinyl for their collectible value (MusicWatch, 2023).
-
Low Overhead: Independent artists use platforms like Bandcamp or CD Baby to produce CDs (
$2/unit) and vinyl ($5–$8/unit), recouping costs after 10–20 sales. -
Cultural Appeal: Vinyl’s retro status and CDs’ affordability make them popular at shows, especially for genres like indie rock (70% vinyl sales) and punk.
-
Data: In 2023, 25% of U.S. physical media sales occurred at concerts, generating ~$475 million, with 60% from vinyl (RIAA). A mid-tier band selling 1,000 CDs annually ($10,000–$12,000) matches 3–4 million streams.
The Decline of Playback Devices: A Critical Barrier
The scarcity of playback devices limits physical media’s accessibility, bolstering streaming’s dominance. CD players are fading, while turntables remain niche despite vinyl’s resurgence.
CD Players: A Fading Presence
-
Market Decline: The global portable CD player market (~$200 million in 2020) is declining at a 2.5% CAGR through 2030. Manufacturers like Sony and Panasonic focus on audiophile models.
-
Retail: Amazon and Best Buy stock budget CD players ($30–$100) and high-end units ($500–$2,000). Sales are <5% of audio equipment in 2023.
-
Used Market: Vintage players (e.g., Marantz CD6007, $100–$500) thrive on eBay, serving audiophiles.
-
Home Audio: CD players dropped from 65% of U.S. households in 2010 to ~20% in 2023, replaced by Bluetooth speakers (Consumer Technology Association).
-
Cars: <10% of 2023 U.S. car models include CD players, down from 80% in 2015, with streaming via Apple CarPlay (80% of models) dominant (Edmunds).
Vinyl Turntables: A Niche Resurgence
-
Market Growth: The turntable market (~$350 million in 2023) grows at 4.5% CAGR through 2030. Entry-level models ($100–$300) drive sales.
-
Availability: Retailers like Target offer Audio-Technica models (~$150). High-end units (e.g., Rega Planar 3, ~$1,000) serve enthusiasts.
-
Demographics: 62% of vinyl buyers are under 35 (RIAA). Maintenance and cost limit mainstream adoption.
-
Data: 7% of U.S. households owned turntables in 2023, vs. 85% with streaming devices (Statista).
Impact on Income: The decline of CD players reduces CD practicality, pushing fans toward streaming or vinyl. However, concertgoers often own turntables (15% of merch buyers, MusicWatch), sustaining vinyl sales at shows.
Why Streaming Wins: Accessibility, Culture, and Income Dynamics
Streaming’s dominance stems from:
-
Playback Scarcity: CD players’ absence in cars (<10%) and homes (<5%) makes CDs impractical. Turntables’ niche status (7% ownership) limits vinyl’s reach, while smartphones (91% U.S. ownership, Pew Research) enable streaming.
-
Convenience: Streaming’s integration with smart speakers (53% of households) and cars (80% with CarPlay) aligns with modern lifestyles.
-
Cost: A $132/year subscription beats 10 CDs ($150) or vinyls ($250), appealing to Gen Z (82% stream).
-
Culture: Younger generations prioritize access over ownership, though vinyl’s retro appeal sustains niche sales.
-
Income Trade-Off: Streaming’s exposure drives tour and merch sales, but its low payouts make physical media more lucrative per unit.
Data:
-
Streaming’s 84% revenue share dwarfs physical media’s 11% and downloads’ 3% ($434 million).
-
U.S. adults spend 1.5 hours daily streaming vs. 0.2 hours on physical media (eMarketer).
-
67% of global listeners used streaming in 2023, with 20% growth in India (IFPI).
Regional and Genre Trends
-
Japan: CDs (49 million units, down 7%) thrive on collectibles; streaming grew 15% to 55% (RIAJ).
-
Germany: CDs (12.9% share, down 5.9%) lag behind vinyl (up 19.4%) (IFPI).
-
UK: CDs fell 2.9% to 10.5 million; vinyl rose 11.7% to 6.2 million (BPI).
-
Genres: Classical/jazz favor CDs (60% sales); pop/hip-hop lean streaming (90%); indie rock boosts vinyl (70%).
Future Outlook
-
CD Players: Sales will decline 3% annually, falling below $150 million by 2030.
-
Turntables: Growth at 4.5% could reach $500 million by 2030, driven by vinyl’s 5–7% unit growth.
-
Streaming: Projected to hit 90% U.S. market share by 2028, with $40 billion globally (IFPI).
-
Artist Income: Physical media at concerts will remain viable, with 30% of merch revenue from CDs/vinyl by 2030, per industry forecasts.
Conclusion
Streaming’s 84% revenue share ($14.4 billion) in 2023, powered by convenience and smartphone ubiquity (91%), overshadows physical media’s 11% ($1.9 billion). Vinyl’s $1.4 billion resurgence (43 million units) and CDs’ $537 million niche (37 million units) offer superior sound, ownership, and collectibility, resonating with 48% of adults. However, CD players’ scarcity (<10% of cars, <5% of audio sales) and turntables’ niche status (7% ownership) drive streaming’s dominance. For artists, physical media is more lucrative—$10–$25 per CD/vinyl at concerts vs. $0.004/stream—with merch tables generating $475 million in 2023. Streaming’s exposure benefits top-tier artists, but mid-tier and independent musicians rely on physical sales’ higher margins. As playback devices wane, streaming’s 90% market share looms, but physical media’s financial viability at shows ensures its enduring role.